OBSERVATIONS
The year 1951 marked the
beginning of our Pointer breeding program. After
a quarter of a century we developed the ideas expressed in the original
Faraway Kennel statement. The millennium will mark almost a
half-century
in the endeavor. Our current pups are our tenth generation. Over the
last
decade or so we have observed changes in field trials and dog breeding
which have not necessarily contributed to the improvement in the breed.
Over the past few years The American Field has published
numerous
interviews with knowledgeable bird-dog folks. The ones conducted by
Karoleigh
Nitchman and Everett Skeehan have been particularly interesting.
Interviews
with such folks as Robin Gates, Rick Furney, Andy Daugherty, and Colvin
Davis are exemplary in bringing out some observations that I have made
over the past decade or so. Others in these series of interviews have
also
said some of the same things. What follows is a list of our
observations
which have been supported by the above mentioned interviews also.
- Judges - There seems to be an increasing number of
judges
who lack
bird hunting experience, never broke a dog, and also who have limited
field trial
experience.
I pay an entry fee to have someone with less field trial experience
than
I and who has never been bird hunting judge my dog. Many major
circuit
trials are judged by individuals whose only qualifications are personal
wealth rather than bird dog experience.
- All-Age / Shooting Dog distinction - All-age dogs are
ranging less
and less, and shooting dogs are running wider. The distinction
between
the two seems to be disappearing. The yardstick used by many
judges
is that of a widely ranging shooting dog. The same dogs win both
kinds of stakes on the same grounds.
- Stamina as a desirable trait - A leading breeder and one
of
the
most influential has stated that three hours is too long for a dog to
run
in a field trial brace. He also stated that a bird dog that can
hunt
all day is no longer relevent.
- Excessive emphasis on tail carriage - I ask: "Do
you
see Greyhounds
with flagpole tails? Why or why not?" This emphasis is also
very related to stamina issue . The dog with the yard fiest type of
artificial
tail carriage doesn't have the stamina of the dog with the whip-tail as
is required by the breed standards.
- Scarcity of quail - This has led to dogs being
trained solely
on liberated birds and has led to generations of dogs that don't know
how
to hunt and handle wild game. While they are nowhere near the
endangered
species category the bob-white is nowhere near as plentiful as they
were
is the past. This is a major contibuting factor to the change
listed
next.
- Decline in number of bird hunters - In this part of the
country
there is almost no bird hunting. Preserves are about the only
place
you can find significant numbers of bird hunters. Those who use
to
hunt have quit or have changed to turkey or deer hunting - both very
abundant
game species here. This, of course, means no demand for bird
dogs.
In the fifties one ad the Richmond Times-Dispatch Sunday classifieds
would be sufficient to
sell
an entire litter. Last year an ad running continuously from
August
to January in Augusta, Macon, and Columbus newspapers sold one pup to a
hunter. The rest were sold as pets.
- The "Don't bother me with the facts, I've made up my mind
syndrome"
- This does not represent a change; it is a condition among field
trialers
(in reference to breeding & buying dogs) that has existed for the
past
half century and continues unabated. Rather than utilizing dogs
for
which substantial evidence exists demonstrating that they are among the
best to which to breed they continue to breed to those in which the
evidence
is just the opposite. Over the past half century only three
excellent
stud dogs have been popular. All of the other very popular ones
could
best be labeled only "Grade B" or lower studs. This includes even
most of those elected to The Field Trial Hall of Fame.
- The popularity of the race horse model over the cattle model-
This
is also not a change. It is a phenomenon that has always existed
and continues today. I am referring to the selection of the brood
bitch.
The question for us now is to what extent should we be influenced by
the above observations. We have been considering this
question for several years and hope to reach some closure soon. At this
point we can say
that we will be influenced in some cases, and we will not be influenced
in others. Our next update will address our answer to the question.
Our new snail mail address is 141 SW Torrance Rd; Milledgeville,
GA 31061
478 452-4653
gno52@windstream.net